2002 Fleer Tradition and Update: Take the Goudey With the Bad

2002 Fleer Tradition #173

In my collection: 1 #173, 1 This Day in History, 1 Diamond Standouts, 1 Curtain Call

Griffey looks: in the midst his amazing swing

Is this a good Griffey card? Yes.  One of the better attempts at old-school by Fleer’s throwback brand.

The set: Done in the style of 1934 Goudey (a design later co-opted by Upper Deck), this year’s version of Tradition is more colorful and endearing than in years past.  Where the original ’34 set featured Lou Gehrig giving alleged quotes about every player, this set has just a team name in some kind of MS Word font.  Ahem.

Now, when Upper Deck did it (in ’09 I think?) they supplanted Gehrig with Griffey, which I like - Fleer on the other hand chose to ignore that whole element and do just the card design.  I must admit that it turned out pretty good - I like these cards.  Colorful and familiar to serious collectors, the base set captures perfectly the essence of old school cardboard; and they are once again printed on the brownest of the brown cardboard, lending a touch of authenticity to the brand’s vintage-ness. 

The inserts, on the other hand, maintain the modernity of any other Fleer set with confusing results.

2002 Fleer Tradition #173

This is a great shot of the Kid in the midst his amazing swing.  Action shots can be boring, but not here.  You can practically feel the weight of the bat in this shot.  It is also silhouetted on the back behind the stats which is a nice touch.

2002 Fleer Tradition This Day in History #17

 

The This Day in History insert marks an important event in the career of yada yada yada, you get the gist from the title, right?  This card marks the Day Junior became the youngest to 300 homeruns.   This record has since been surpassed by multiple players, and it is currently held by Alex Rodriguez who reached the mark at 27 years, 249 days old.  I swear I don’t know how that guy does it.  Oh, wait.  Yes, I do.

These cards are smooth and shiny and feel out of place among cards printed on brown cardboard.  The baseballs below the portrait are raised.  The update version also includes this insert - for that one Fleer chose the day Junior got his 2000^th hit.  I don’t have that card to show you, so you’ll just have to take my word for it.

The Update set for Tradition was Fleer’s first set that was put together entirely after 9/11, so it is very patriotic indeed.  They were nice enough to include Junior in a couple of very patriotic subsets, and here they are:

2002 Fleer Tradition Update #U297 Statistical Standouts

Basically this card is saying that Griffey had a great June.  They mention his 2,000th hit almost in passing, and they use a comma in the blurb where they should have used a semicolon.  Even as a Griffey fan I find this card a little boring.

2002 Fleer Tradition Update #U364 Curtain Call

Then there’s this card.  I love this card!  It’s patriotic without being ostentatious, and the theme is solid.  Plus it’s a great-looking design with seamless carryover from front to back.  My only gripe is that it shows our guy coming in from playing outfield where there should be a shot of him batting.  Despite that, this is my favorite Fleer Tradition card from ‘02.

And don't forget this from the base card:

 

Here are the cards from 2002 Fleer Tradition and Update I am missing:

#173 Glossy #/200

Heads Up #5

Update:

#U297 Diamond Standouts Glossy #/200

#U364 Curtain Call Glossy #/200

This Day in History #U4

Plays of the Week #7

Despite a few minor issues this may be the best year Fleer Tradition.  Not bad, guys.

Leggo My Logo: 2013 Pinnacle

2013 Pinnacle #104

In my collection: 1 #104, 1 Awaiting the Call, 1 Swing for the Fences, 1 Team Pinnacle Junior front, 1 Team pinnacle Trout front, 1 Clear Vision Double

Griffey looks: out

Is this a good Griffey card?  Yes.  Pinnacle’s first set in fifteen years, and Junior got several cards.

The set: Pinnacle’s return after a fifteen year absence came as a surprise to me.  I had heard nothing about it until I happened upon Baseballcardpedia one day and there it was on the home page.  I know Panini is starting to build market presence with their Triple Play, Cooperstown, and Prizm sets; but having just assembled what I thought was going to be Pinnacle’s entire Design Timeline, I obviously was not expecting any more cards from this brand.  The implications of this move are very exciting.

Panini owns Donruss and Leaf as well as all of the Pinnacle brands which include Select and Score.  I know you’re thinking that without a license the cards can't be too great, but they seem to be making do with the brands they’re releasing already, are they not?  View from the Skybox had a pretty positive response to his Prizm group break, so people do want the cards.  I bet this is not the last brand we see that makes a comeback.  I hope it’s not - this market needs the competition. 

And I don’t want to quote myself, but I have been requesting throwback sets for several of the more popular ‘90’s designs.  This seems like more of a possibility now than ever.

So how did they do with Pinnacle?  The design aesthetic seems intact, remaining as angular and bold as ever.  The original logo is back as are a couple of the inserts and that great Dufex printing.  The lack of gold foil is very noticeable, but overall this still feels like a Pinnacle card. 

The most glaring difference, even more than the lack of logos, is the lack of variety among the photos.  There are a whole lot of shots of Griffey at the top of his swing where his body is turned sideways and the absence of logos can slip by unnoticed.  This major limitation on Panini is handled gracefully on most of the cards, but more variety among the pictures would help particularly because much of the card verbiage touts Junior’s prowess as an outfielder.  Number of fielding photos used?  Zero.

Here are the Griffeys:

2013 Pinnacle #104

This is clearly a pop-fly.  Look at the angle of his gaze - he’s looking straight up.  Junior is more than likely out.  Then again, maybe there’s a runner on third and this is a sac fly.  We may never know.

I think the inspiration for the base card design here must have come from that first ’92 Pinnacle set.  The black-and-greyed-out background, the subtle white framing, the touch of team-appropriate color - these are similar elements to those from the ’92 set.  And even though the ’92 set didn’t have it, again, I miss the foil.

Awaiting the Call # AC10

Awaiting the Call appears to be the most common of the inserts.  There’s no gold foil or holofoil or translucence like you can find in the other inserts.  Plus it’s got the same angled corners as the base set, so frankly this looks more like a subset.  While the paragraph is nice, I would also like to have seen some HOF-worthy stats on the back, though I’m not entirely against that circular logo.  Overall, meh.

There are two versions of this next insert, so bear with me.

Griffey front version:

 

2013 Pinnacle Team Pinnacle #TP3, Griffey front

Trout front version:

2013 Pinnacle Team Pinnacle #TP3, Trout front

I instantly remembered this insert from Pinnacle sets of the past, but this year we have a major improvement that only a long-time collector would recognize.  In old TP insert sets, one player always got the better-looking side of the card.  In 2013, however, each player gets a version where they have the better side.  Totally fair.  Interestingly, both cards have the same number.  Here’s both versions for comparison.

Another interesting aspect is that placement of that MLBPA logo - it’s always on Trout.  I figure that’s probably there because Trout is an active player and Griffey is not, but it could also be an error.  Let’s get our extensive legal team on this.

Hey, I hope you like that picture, because....

2013 Pinnacle Clear Vision #CV75 Double

Here it is again.  That’s right - Team Pinnacle has the same picture as Clear Vision.  I’ll let it slide, though, as the card itself is pretty cool.  The red-tinted section is translucent plastic framed by the rest of the card which is in holofoil.  The field is red here but the colors vary by which type you pull.  They range in rarity from Single to Home Run, and there is also a Circuit card that is a 1/1.  This looks like one of those cards where they shape the blurb paragraph to fit the player silhouette on the back….

Whoops - strike that, reverse it.  At least we got a career line at the bottom there.  Enjoy that.

2013 Pinnacle Swing for the Fences #SF4

The Swing for the Fences insert is another that was around during Pinnacle’s original run in the 90’s.  It’s very similar to the Clear Vision card in that it sports an opaque player silhouette over translucent effects.  I bet this time they got the back right - come on, Griffey-shaped blurb!  Show me the blurb!  Bluuuuurb!

Denied again.  Not even a stat line this time.  Lucky for us the card design speaks metaphorical volumes.  The background here is transparent plastic with white printing to simulate wood grain.  Hence, it is a non-fence.  Such a fence is easily penetrable by light and, presumably, baseballs.  The message here is that for the power hitters of this insert, the fence may as well not even be there.

There are quite a few Juniors in this set, and I am missing a whole lot of them:

#104 Museum Collection

#104 Artist Proof

#104 Blue Artist Proof

Awaiting the Call #AC10 Museum Collection

Awaiting the Call #AC10 Artist Proof

Awaiting the Call #AC10 Blue Artist proof

Essence of the Game #EG3

Clear Vision #CV75 Single

Clear Vision #CV75 Triple

Clear Vision #CV75 Home Run

Clear Vision #CV75 Cycle 1/1

Autographs #46

There are so many more sets I want to see return!  I am still amazed Topps hasn't brought back Stadium Club (correctly, I mean).  There's money to be made as all us collectors from the 90's rediscover our cardboard and start shoveling our disposable incomes into the engines of capitalism.

Logos or not, this is a step in the right direction.

2000 Fleer Tradition and Update: Twizzlers Approved

2000 Fleer Tradition #222

In my collection: 1 #222 regular, 1 #222 glossy, 1 Team Twizzler #7, 1 #1 League Leader HR, 1 #3 League Leader RBI, 3 Dividends, 3 Ten-4, 1 Update #23, 1 Update #1 Season Highlights

Griffey looks: determined

Is this a good Griffey card? Yes.  A classic design, albeit not entirely original, and Fleer's first foray into the nostalgia market.

The set: Fleer Tradition was first introduced in 1998, but this ain’t your daddy’s Fleer Tradition. 

The very early 2000’s saw a massive shift in focus to more nostalgic sets.  The rehashing of classic designs and printing techniques was suddenly rampant as all the major brands scrambled to claim their roles as ambassadors of the past. 

 

Obviously Topps would have little competition as masters of the throwback set - they had been putting out an unbroken line of consecutive sets since 1952, produced several throwbacks under the Archives brand, and also owned Bowman who was the only other brand who could possibly challenge them.  In 2001 Topps brought back its Archives brand and Bowman and Topps both began their Heritage sub-brands. 

Poor Donruss was still bouncing back from bankruptcy and eager to remind collectors of their significance; hence, along came Donruss Originals in 2001.  They only made the set for one year, though, and I’m still waiting for a reprint of my beloved ’89 set.

Also Upper Deck, not having a history beyond 1989, came out with its groovy pseudo-throwback Decade 70’s set.  It didn’t seem to have the desired effect with the collecting community.

The only brand that could even try to give Topps a run for their money was Fleer.  They had produced three sets from 1959 to 1963 before disappearing for 18 years only to be reintroduced when MLB started handing out rights contracts in 1981.  Fleer had also never ceased production since that reintroduction.  They had more of a case for being called a classic brand and the pedigree to back up a decent throwback set. 

By 2000 Fleer had already inundated the market with new sets in an attempt to snatch up the market share left by the numerous failing brands, and in doing that they released a brand called Tradition in 1998.  Strangely, it had no business being called Tradition in the sense that we now think of the brand.  The base cards and inserts were modern, glossy, and covered in foil; hence, there was nothing traditional about them.  This leads me to believe the brand name at that time was poking fun of the fact that so many brands were disappearing while Fleer appeared to prosper. 

Thus in a smart lateral move, Fleer reintroduced Tradition as a retro brand.  The name made sense for its new purpose, and it eliminated what was essentially another pointless brand.  Pretty slick, Fleer.

One aspect of the new Tradition that is evident in several of their sets is that the designers took their inspiration from classic Topps designs of the 50’s and 60’s.  The 2000 set is inspired rather shamelessly by the 1954 Topps set.  I find this surprising as this is a brand that actually made cards in the 50’s and 60’s.  They have their own designs to re-hash - why go straight for another company’s design for inspiration?

I do like how they printed the base set on brown cardboard.  The cards feel like sturdy, high-quality vintage.

Here are the Griffeys:

Griffey looks determined, son!  Look at this face.  You can’t help hearing those nuns from The Sound of Music belting out “Climb Every Mountain.”  He’s like, “Yes. Yes, I will climb.  Every.        Mountain.”  Nice portrait.  The design, however, is far from perfect.  The background color is just the worst.  Also the white circle around the logo is huge.  Why is it so huge?  Everything else about the card is just alright.  I do like how the smaller action shot Griffey is standing on the card border like one of The Littles.

There are actually three versions of this card:

2000 Fleer Tradition #222 regular, glossy, Team Twizzlers #7

The cards are identical on the front apart from a high-gloss on the glossy version.  The Twizzlers promo card is printed in a pretty standard way on white card stock.  The backs are identical apart from the word "Glossy" and the little Team Twizzlers logo.

I prefer Red Vines, but far be it from me to prevent anyone here from getting their Twizz on.

 

2000 Fleer Tradition #1 League Leaders HR

Junior looks good here, as does Delgado.  Very conscientious and proud to be League Leaders.  But what is the deal with Raf?  That is the most unhealthy picture of him I’ve ever seen.  He looks like Tommy Wiseau, all pale and lumpy.  This card is 33% upsetting.

2000 Fleer Tradition #3 League Leaders RBI

Ditto.  Griffey tied Delgado in RBIs, so I don't know how they decided to bump Carlos off this card.  I guess it was star power that made the decision here.

 

2000 Fleer Tradition Dividends #D14

Flipped-up shades, bro.  Catch you on the flippy-flip, cuz I flip-flop, I can’t stop, and my flippy shippies like to snip-snop my dip-dop flip-flop scrim-scram flippy-dippy.  Boom.  Flipped-up shades.

The back of this card compares Junior to the Dow Jones.  Frankly the concept here isn’t bad, but I would like to have seen some graphs with up-slanting red lines, maybe a stock ticker tied to actual stats.  Perhaps a bull, or a Wall Street sign.  Something.  Instead, flipped-up shades.  They missed the mark in every department that does not involve shades.  

2000 Fleer Tradition Hall's Well #HW9

Worst. Scan. Ever.

Printed on translucent plastic, this is almost the perfect card in a utilitarian sense.  It’s got no corners to damage as they have all been rounded out.  It is sufficiently thick that you could probably cut a soft cheese with it, wash it in the sink, and slip it right back into its top loader with nobody the wiser.  I bet grading companies like PSA pull these out of envelopes and just slap 10’s on them sight unseen.  This is the Nokia cell phone of baseball cards - it will damage you before you damage it.

2000 Fleer Tradition Ten-4 #TF5

Man, oh, man.  I’ve wanted to write about this card for so long.  Please excuse me if I indulge.

This insert has the dignified simplicity of an Animal Collective song - there are just a whole lot of things going on at once here.  I want to say to this card, “Hey, card.  Why do you look like that?”  To which the card would almost certainly reply “!!!AWKB!DLU5rg8B!!!!SLKLeWKJND!!!!!!!!!1!!!!!”  I mean, look at it.  It’s the Tazmanian Devil of baseball cards.   

I usually try saying a few words about each design, but it’s hard to pick where to start with this one.  I’ll give it a try: ummmm, he’s farting a baseball.  There’s a good start.  The ball is huge, too - I’m hoping that’s a perspective thing.

The design here raises a lot of questions about how this card was produced.  Questions like what is the purpose of the die-cutting here?  Why is Junior glowing like one of the aliens from Cocoon?  Why are the logo and name in that awkward, not-quite-centered spot?  What is that little white diamond?  Is it on there because it has four sides?  Why is it called Ten-4?  Why not Roger, or Message Received, or Over and Out?  Is it something to do with walkie-talkies or HAM radios that I’m completely missing?  Was the die-cut necessary for the theme?  What is the theme?

My only guess as to the theme here was grand slams which score four runs.  Having read the backs of most of these cards, that definitely is not it.  Maybe it's four bases, the number you touch after a home run?  And the white diamond is a base?  Well then what is the significance of ten?  Whatever.  This card is bananas.

There is one thing that I love about this card.  While there is a plethora of unreasonable die-cut craziness, that left edge is laid out perfectly for slipping this card into sleeves.  Start with the card tilted to the left, slip the sharp corner into the sleeve, then rotate the rest of the card until vertical and slide it on in.  It rests on a flat edge, so it remains undamaged pretty easily.  Also, this card is an octagon.  Crazy, right?

They say a camel is a horse designed by committee.  If that’s true, this is a blue camel with twelve humps and a propeller.  You can get this monstrosity for 45 cents on COMC, but if you handle it too much you’ll go blind.  Play it safe.

Come to think of it, Over and Out is actually a pretty awesome name for a power hitter insert.

While we're here, let's knock out the Update set.  It was released as a factory-packaged complete set only.  There were no packs nor inserts.

2000 Fleer Tradition Update #U23

Griffey's first Fleer card as a Cincinnati Red.  The yellow background would have been more appropriate on the Mariners card, but it still looks great here.  Nice picture, too.

2000 Fleer Tradition Update #1 Season Highlights

This is a solid highlights card - a picture of the act and a nice description.  It's not flashy, but they gave Junior card #1 in the set which I consider an honor.

There are no particularly rare cards from this set apart from three one-offs from the Hawaii Trade Conference. Here are the Griffeys I am missing from 2000 Fleer Tradition:

#1 2000 AL Home Run League Leaders Glossy /10000

#1 2000 AL Home Run League Leaders Glossy Hawaii Trade Conference 1/1

#3 2000 AL Home Run League Leaders Glossy /10000

#3 2000 AL Home Run League Leaders Glossy Hawaii Trade Conference 1/1

#49 Checklist

#49 Checklist Glossy /1000

#49 Checklist Glossy Hawaii Trade Conference 1/1

#222 Glossy Hawaii Trade Conference 1/1

Grass Kickers #GK10

I have barely scratched the surface on Fleer during this time.  This is a brand that put out a whopping 30 sets from 2000-2002.  Thirty.  And those are just the ones released under the Fleer name.  There are more.  Crazy.

Enjoy your football this weekend, and Geaux Saints!